Recipe Search EngineRestaurant GuideFood PhotosBlogCookbook ReviewsHelp

Search For:
Location:
Cuisine:

Show Best


NY-Style Pizza Showdown

Who makes the best NY-style pizza in SD?
Read more »

Help Us Improve
FoodieView
Add A Restaurant
Edit Restaurant Info
Add A New Link




San Diego
Dining Guides

Sicilian Thing Pizza

4046 30th St
San Diego, CA 92104
(619) 282-3000

Web Links: 3 Links
Avg Rating:
  81 Ratings
Add To List
Write A Review

 
[large map] [get directions]

More Details

Price:   $ (Less than $10)
Categories:   Pizza
User Tags:   new pizza sicilian york

Is our information wrong or incomplete? Let us know.

Foodieview Member Reviews

Sicilian Pizza in San Diego
Reviewed By howie Sep 22, 2007
Tags: sicilian new york pizza

When I was driving down 30th a few weeks ago, I noticed a sign for a new pizza place with the intriguing name of A Sicilian Thing. Could it be that someone in San Diego has decided to specialize in Sicilian-style pizza (if you don't count Pizza Hut)? Sicilian-style pizza in America usually refers to a rectangular pizza with a thick crust -- almost like focaccia bread, but with a nice crunch on the bottom.

It turns out that A Sicilian Thing was started by a Bronx Pizza alumnus. That's all I needed to hear before checking it out. I stopped by soon after. They sell about half a dozen varieties of Sicilian pizza by the slice, as well as a couple of NY-style thin crust pies. I was also pleasantly surprised that they sell cannolis too.

I ordered 2 Sicilian slices, a pepperoni and a meat combo called The Meatda. The quality of ingredients was great and the sauce was nicely balanced. The crust was pretty good, but I noticed that it was a bit tough. My jaw was pretty tired after finishing the second slice.

On a separate visit, I ordered a couple of their New York-style slices. It's very similar to Bronx Pizza's, which should come as no surprise. I think the crust on these thin slices was even a little better than Bronx's, though not as good as Luigi's. I think the slices were a bit low on sauce (and I tend not to like too much sauce on my pizza).

I couldn't resist trying the cannoli also, but it was a bit of a letdown. The shell had a crisp, light texture, but the filling had an odd chalky texture.

I think I prefer Hoboken Pizza in PB for both Sicilian-style and NY- style pizza. Hoboken's crust has a lighter feel to it, and their more assertive sauce cuts through the extra bread. But at A Sicilian Thing, you have a lot more choice of Sicilian slices. Overall, A Sicilian Thing is a great addition to the San Diego pizza scene, and I foresee many future visits here, especially since I'm too lazy to park and wait in line at Bronx or drag myself to PB for Hoboken.



Critic And Customer Reviews

Listed below are links to reviews of Sicilian Thing Pizza from around the web.

entertainment.signonsandiego.com review
[report bad link]
[more from entertainment.signonsandiego]
"Don't leave without a cannoli. Duh...."
local.yahoo.com review
[report bad link]
[more from local.yahoo]
"Not worth it: I can't believe that people are raving about this place! My company frequently has its luncheons and retirement parties here and I have to say: this food is insulting to any semi-epicurian...."

80 reviews  
sdeats.blogspot.com review
[report bad link]
[more from sdeats.blogspot]
"I'm told that this is yet another Bronx spin-off (they don't mention it on the website, so maybe I got that wrong. Well if they only offered NY style, I'd say that there was no more room in North Park for yet another NY pizzeria...."

Are we missing a review of this restaurant on the web?
Click here to let us know.

Close
Login To Create Lists
Starting Address:   Close

Restaurant address data provided by Acxiom