Recipe Search EngineRestaurant GuideBlogCookbook ReviewsCooking ResourcesHelp

Search For:
Location:
Cuisine:

Show Best


Help Us Improve
FoodieView
Add A Restaurant
Edit Restaurant Info
Add A New Link




New York City
Dining Guides

Carmine's

200 W 44th St
New York, NY 10036
(212) 221-3800

Awards: 1 Awards
Web Links: 16 Links
Avg Rating:
  549 Ratings
Add To List
Write A Review

 
[large map] [get directions]

More Details

Menu:   [see menu] (allmenus.com)
Categories:   Italian
User Tags:  

Is our information wrong or incomplete? Let us know.


Carmine's has been selected as a best restaurant by a major publication or website.



Foodieview Member Reviews

No member reviews posted yet.

Be The First To Write A Review

Critic And Customer Reviews

Listed below are links to reviews of Carmine's from around the web.

dinesite.com review
[report bad link]
[more from dinesite]
"If you don't reserve you can expect up to a two-hour wait at this perpetually popular midtown Italian supper club. It's a handsome, caramel-toned Frank Sinatra sort of place, hung with medieval chandeliers and old photos, and filled with what can be a dea..."
fodors.com review
[report bad link]
[more from fodors]
"Savvy New Yorkers line up early for the affordable family-style meals (read: massive portions to share) at this large, busy eatery. There are no reservations taken for parties of fewer than six people after 7 PM, but those who wait are rewarded with mount..."

8 reviews  
frommers.com review
[report bad link]
[more from frommers]
"Everything is B-I-G at this rollicking family-style mainstay with two locations, on the Upper West Side (the original) and in Times Square. Carmine's, with a dining room vast enough to deserve its own zip code, and massive portions, remarkably turns out b..."
gayot.com review
[report bad link]
[more from gayot]
"Discuss what's going on in the New York dining scene in the Gayot Community Forum. Let us know which restaurants you think dish up the Best Pizza in Manhattan and beyond or which New York City Bakeries satisfy your sweet tooth...."
insiderpages.com review
[report bad link]
[more from insiderpages]
"Menus are posted on the wall and don't panic when you see a price like $34. It's best to go with at least 2 other people, the more the better because you can try more dishes...."

1 reviews  
judysbook.com review
[report bad link]
[more from judysbook]
"I've been to this restaurant about 4-5 times and I've never been surprised by the fact that the taste of this restaurant's food has been seemingly mass produced. Carmine's has developed a reputation of being one of the best Italian Restaurants in NYC...."

8 reviews  
local.yahoo.com review
[report bad link]
[more from local.yahoo]
"Company Information: A Theatre District favorite, Carmine's features large servings of good Southern Italian food. Portions are family style (meaning huge), and sharing is recommended...."

258 reviews  
newyork.metromix.com review
[report bad link]
[more from newyork.metromix]
"Carmine's is a great spot for groups (the bigger the group the better), as the food is served family-style. Anyone who doesn't feel like sharing with fellow meal-mates will end up carting home a huge doggie bag...."
nyc.com review
[report bad link]
[more from nyc]
nymag.com review
[report bad link]
[more from nymag]
"Using the same formula that’s kept its Upper West Side sibling cooking on all burners, it’s a roaring success, with a high-spirited old-time atmosphere, mammoth portions that demand to be shared, and uncomplicated Southern Italian cooking that delights th..."
savorynewyork.com review
[report bad link]
[more from savorynewyork]
"Shrimp scampi is a veritable school of plump crustaceans dusted with bread crumbs and broiled with scads of butter, garlic, and clam juice...."
search.cityguide.aol.com review
[report bad link]
[more from search.cityguide.aol]
"With two Manhattan locations -- Midtown and the Upper West Side -- Carmine's packs them in with simple, solid, family-style Italian food. The Times Square incarnation is perpetually busy, and not just because it's located in the heart of the Theater Distr..."

274 reviews  
travel.yahoo.com review
[report bad link]
[more from travel.yahoo]
"Savvy New Yorkers line up early for the affordable family-style meals served at this large, busy eatery. The dining room has dark woodwork and old-fashioned black-and-white tiles...."
tripadvisor.com review
[report bad link]
[more from tripadvisor]
"Explore our site to find travel information and unbiased reviews on New York City tourism, hotels, attractions, maps and much more...."
wcities.com review
[report bad link]
[more from wcities]
"A Theatre District favorite, Carmine"s features large servings of good Southern Italian food. Portions are family style (meaning huge), and sharing is recommended...."
yelp.com review
[report bad link]
[more from yelp]

Are we missing a review of this restaurant on the web?
Click here to let us know.

Close
Login To Create Lists
Starting Address:   Close

Restaurant address data provided by Acxiom